never really bought it when managers and front office execs and players say
they don’t read the sports page. To me
it’s always seemed sort of akin to 450,000 people claiming they were in the
stands for Nolan’s 7th no-hitter. Some
are telling the truth. Most aren’t.
this week I retreated a little on that.
It started to make sense to me why ballplayers and team personnel might
choose to ignore what’s being written about them. This week, I felt like trying the boycott
out. Never did, but I was tempted, at
least on one particular subject.
been stunning to me how abruptly the Michael Young story, which began on Sunday
evening with a national Fox Sports article that everyone in the local press had
the same access to, and was followed by a conference call with Jon Daniels that
everyone in the local press was on, rotted into a self-righteous column-inch
scrap between writers who cover the Rangers.
I get the possible irony, the potential for coming across as self-righteous
myself here. I’m sure I’m guilty of it
at times, though on this story I’ve tried to keep my eye on the ball and not
try to make what someone else wrote
the story, or even part of it.)
are lots of writers in town whose opinions I respect a lot and, more
importantly, whose access and diligence and writing ability I depend on. But this has turned into Kenny Rogers &
the Cameraman, a story that has writers taking sides and taking shots (some
less veiled than others) at each other because of what they did or didn’t do
(or get to do) and because of the stance they are taking.
as if these writers decided that this story required them, after taking sides
on the issue at hand (assigning guilt to one party or the other, ignoring the
less provocative possibility that all who were involved could have handled
things a bit better), to throw a low blow at the writers in town who took a
different position. “I’m Bloggy
McColumnist, and I approve this message.”
the object, for at least one of the writers in question, is to attempt to drive
a wedge at the top of the Rangers’ front office, or at least create a
perception among Rangers fans that such a wedge already exists, that’s pretty
sorta funny offshoot of this is that we now have columnists training bloggers
in their crosshairs; meanwhile, the style some of them have resorted to this
week smacks of blogging at its worst (and to some who don’t pay better
attention, blogging as a whole).
the last time the local media has behaved so badly on a baseball story? I suggested to a fellow blogger yesterday
that it was the Rogers
fiasco. He said no, this has been
worse. He’s probably right.
do get that nerves are probably on edge like never before in that
industry. Hours after the Young story
broke, the Dallas Morning News and Fort Worth Star-Telegram acknowledged
in print a development that had been rumored for weeks: that in February the
two papers – the two rivals – would
begin to collaborate on a huge chunk of their sports coverage. The Star-Telegram
will be responsible for the Rangers beat.
The News will keep the
Mavericks and Stars beats. Each will
cover the Cowboys.
really sad. A survival tactic, sure,
given the deathbed that many have suggested the newspaper industry was on even
before the economy fell apart. But sad.
following happened the morning after the Cowboys’ final game of the season.
watched the pathetic game, I watched the postgame interviews, I watched the
studio shows. I read the papers the next
morning. But the best piece of reporting
I heard after the disaster came not from any of the above, but rather a radio
Ticket’s Mark Friedman said on Norm Hitzges’s air on Monday morning, December
29, that he was on the team plane the night before, coming back to Dallas from
Philadelphia, and that a significant fraction of the players who had just
embarrassed themselves and their organization, arguably worse than any
collection from the nearly 50-year-old franchise had ever done in a 60-minute
span, were goofing around during the flight, laughing, playing games, acting as
if it were the last day of school.
didn’t raise a megaphone and bluster on about what Jimmy Johnson would have
done about it if he were still coaching here, or whether a team with Bob Lilly
or Roger Staubach or Lee Roy Jordan or Michael Irvin or Troy Aikman on it would
ever have acted like that.
simply reported, and I thought it was a pretty useful piece of
information. Said a lot, by itself,
about what the Cowboys are, and what they aren’t. There were interesting columns written that
week, but none I appreciated more than that one brief report I got by listening
to the radio that morning.
newspaper beat merger is very disappointing, as a Rangers fan. I have no doubt that the Star-Telegram‘s Jeff Wilson and Anthony Andro will continue to do a
great job, as will MLB.com’s T.R. Sullivan, but as fans we’re all better off if
Evan Grant and Richard Durrett are out there on the beat as well.
is not a flare crying for baseball bloggers to get more credibility, more
credit. Far from it. Really, it’s just the opposite. Without beat reporters, good ones, columnists
are emasculated. And so are
bloggers. And so are fans.
is also not a comment on the bigger picture, the advent of a newspaper as
established and influential as the Dallas Morning News dropping one of its
major pro sports beats. That’s another
issue, a larger one. Nothing about it
signals anything good. But that’s not
what this is about.
been fortunate to have very good beat reporters covering the Rangers for
years. The idea that the two lead papers
are trading in good old-fashioned competition and all the good that that
entails in exchange for a joint enterprise, in the name of economic measure,
means several things to us, some by definition: the result will be less volume
of information, fewer feature stories (which generally don’t overlap), fewer
it also mean the reporters surviving the transition, faced with less
competition, will be less aggressive, in their sense of urgency if not in their
know. Hope not.
nobody would dispute that heightened competition tends to bring out the best in
beat reporters, why read the sports page?
I have friends among this market’s columnists, but if I want to read
analysis on the Texas Rangers, I’m not sure there’s one of them whose work I’d
seek out before checking Adam Morris’s
daily blog work, or Mike Hindman’s, or Joey Matschulat and Jason Parks’s.
not a knock on our local columnists (at least not all of them), but while those
who write with a major newspaper byline have more access to the organization
than the blogging community, that’s less of an issue considering how
infrequently most of them use that access.
There’s so little hard-hitting baseball column-writing done in DFW – not
because the baseball columns are weak, but because they are non-existent (or at
least were until this week’s story that everyone weighed in on). Go grab a stack of local papers from any
given July – July! – and scoreboard the number of Rangers columns against the
number of Cowboys training camp columns.
Bet even in the baseball team’s playoff years, the tally wasn’t close.
the beat reporters are there every day.
Talking to the players, to the General Manager, to the President, to the
Owner. No team’s General Manager or
President is as accessible, cooperative, or candid as Jon Daniels and Nolan
Ryan. Having fewer good reporters on the
beat to take advantage of that availability is no good.
the “beatwriter co-operative” idea that Mark Cuban floated last month (www.blogmaverick.com) the
solution? I don’t know. Cuban’s idea is to create a company that
funds multiple writers in each market, charged with covering multiple sports
but in greater print-only depth than space permits in their current situations.
if it has legs, it’s impossible to imagine that anything would be in place this
there are some smart, bold folks out there already working on ways to keep the
Rangers beat from depopulating.
few quick things:
Vizquel is from Caracas, Venezuela, which is closer to Elvis Andrus’s
hometown of Maracay than Andrus’s 2008 home
(Frisco) is to his expected 2009 address (Arlington).
some merit to this speculation that Texas
could sign the 41-year-old Vizquel now that Young has agreed to become the
Rangers’ third baseman. Young will be a
terrific mentor to Andrus (he’s already begun: check out the pointed remarks he
made this week about how unfair the media treatment of this story has been to
the 20-year-old), but on the field he’ll be busy working his tail off to get
comfortable with the nuances of his new position. Ian Kinsler will surely be to Andrus what
Alex Rodriguez was to Young, and what Young was to Kinsler, taking Andrus under
his wing as they grow into a long-term double play combination. But as for the mindset and the actions of a
shortstop, it makes huge sense to have the 11-time Gold Glove winner, who
should be very affordable and happy to take a one-year deal, around to work
with his fellow Venezuelan in camp.
for whether it makes sense to have a player like Vizquel on the bench in April
is another question. He offers less
versatility than a player like Joaquin Arias or German Duran would, but if
Andrus hits .150 for a month and prompts an option to Oklahoma (whether that’s
in March or May), neither Arias nor Duran is likely to be counted on to play
shortstop every day – and you certainly wouldn’t move Young back to shortstop
and interrupt the rhythm he’ll be developing at third base. Vizquel would be an ideal stopgap.
hey: maybe having Vizquel around in March as a mentor makes it less likely,
even slightly, that Andrus gets overwhelmed and overmatched in his first run
through the American League.
Vizquel has been a 20-year favorite of mine.
Stupid little story; I may tell it if he signs here.
thought to tuck away: unless the CBA were to change in this regard over the
next six years (which I’d guess is unlikely), if Andrus spends a dozen days in
the minor leagues this year, he can’t become a free agent until after the 2015
season. If he never sees another day on
the farm, he’ll be a free agent after the 2014 season, at age 26.
Andrus has an outstanding camp, I expect him to be the Opening Day shortstop,
but remember: Evan Longoria had an OPS over 1.000 for the Rays in spring
training last year and didn’t make the team.
Tampa Bay purchased his contract on April 12,
and while that club probably didn’t admit that it was securing an extra year of
control by doing so, it was obviously a factor, given the almost immediate
purchase less than two weeks into the season.
(Although, six days after that, the Rays signed Longoria to a six-year
contract with three club option years, wiping out the issue except to the extent
that the first option year, if declined, becomes an arbitration year rather
than a free agency year.)
Andrus were to spend close to two months on the farm, it could also prevent him
from becoming a Super Two arbitration-eligible after the 2011 season. But that’s less significant, obviously, than
the free agency issue.
the way, Arias has one option remaining.
Travis Metcalf, same.
Freddy Garcia – also from Caracas – has
reportedly narrowed his choices for his next employer down to the Rangers,
White Sox, Yankees, and Mets, with Chicago
considered the possible frontrunner.
Righthander Kris Benson is apparently considering the Rangers,
Cardinals, Dodgers, and Diamondbacks.
He’ll throw for scouts a week from today.
Scott Lucas pointed out on Wednesday, Texas signed catcher Brandon Harrigan to
a minor league contract (surely he’s related to former Rangers farmhand Hunter
Harrigan, also a catcher – both attended the same Colorado high school and
played collegiately at Cowley County Community College), and released
righthander Keisuke Ueno, lefthander Ryan Turner, and outfielders Rafael Hill
and Kyle Murphy.
Rangers also signed infielder Royce Huffman to a minor league contract. The 32-year-old TCU product spent the first
eight of his 10 pro seasons in the Astros chain.
Florida signed lefthander John Koronka (who spent part of
2008 pitching in Japan)
to a minor league deal. The White Sox
signed righthander Franklyn German and catcher Chris Stewart to minor league
deals. Pittsburgh signed outfielder Craig Monroe to
a minor league deal. Seattle signed outfielder Freddy Guzman to a
minor league deal. Kansas City gave catcher Cody Clark a new
minor league deal.
Seattle hired Steve Hecht
to be its performance coach. Tampa Bay
named Todd Greene its quality assurance coach.
Sioux Falls Canaries of the independent American Association released
outfielder Will Smith.
need to read Jason Parks’s spectacular interview with lefthander Martin Perez,
whose upside is as great as Derek Holland’s and Neftali Feliz’s and Michael
Main’s. Check it out at
Texas invited Holland,
Feliz, Andrus, first baseman Justin Smoak, and catchers Manny Pina and Kevin
Richardson to big league spring training (no surprises there), joining
righthanders Casey Daigle, Brian Gordon, Doug Mathis, Elizardo Ramirez, and
Derrick Turnbow and lefthander Joe Torres as non-roster invites so far.
club is holding a Winter Development Camp Monday through Friday, with 19
pitchers and three catchers (Richardson, Jarrod Saltalamacchia, and Taylor
Teagarden) attending. One pitchers’
group (John Bannister, Blake Beavan, Thomas Diamond, Matt Harrison, Holland, Kasey Kiker,
Luis Mendoza, Guillermo Moscoso, and Tim Murphy) will throw on Monday and
Wednesday. The second group (Michael
Ballard, Feliz, Tommy Hunter, Eric Hurley, Andrew Laughter, Warner Madrigal,
Michael Main, Mathis, Brandon McCarthy, and Omar Poveda) will throw on Tuesday
and Thursday. The Friday session is
optional. There will be on-field
workouts, conditioning drills, and classroom sessions.
list of 19 pitchers appears to encompass the group slated to be at Bakersfield or higher
this spring with the best chance of impacting the big league rotation in the
next few years. The two names I might
have expected to be included that weren’t: left-handed relievers Beau Jones and
if not all, of the campers will be on hand for next Saturday’s FanFest, and
historically players not on the 40-man roster end up at the Newberg Report
booth to sign autographs. I’ll have a
lot more detail to share with you about FanFest on Monday, with updates as the
Max Ramirez, who led the Venezuelan Winter League in regular season home runs
and hit .298/.391/.618, finishing among the league leaders in almost every key
production category, was named VWL Rookie of the Year.
apparently won’t show the “Homecoming with Rick Reilly” episode featuring Josh
Hamilton again until April 22.
won’t get into the debate I had with Norm Hitzges Thursday night at the House
of Blues, which he took briefly to the air on Friday morning and which I spent
too much time talking about on message boards on Friday afternoon. All I’ll say here is two things: (1) I don’t
understand his preference of moving Young to second base, Kinsler to left
field, Chris Davis to third base, and Ramirez to first base (and David Murphy
or Nelson Cruz to the bench) – seems to me that you’d be putting half your
lineup at positions that wouldn’t be their best, and asking that many players
to learn new positions at once would be a recipe for some very bad defensive
nights early in the year; and (2) as for his argument that Young would be
less-than-average at third base offensively, so what? Your lineup is your lineup.
you want your best defensive lineup on the field, not worrying about how your
players compare offensively to others in the league at their position? Let’s say, hypothetically, that Young’s
offense measures up better vis a vis others at his position if he were at
second base, and that Kinsler’s production looks more like a third
baseman’s. Either way, Young and Kinsler
are in your lineup – don’t you want them at that point at the defensive
positions that make the most sense?
again hypothetically, let’s say your offense suffers some, for whatever reason,
because Young is at third instead of second (which makes no sense to me). So you go from the game’s best offense to,
what, its third or fourth best? Doesn’t
seem like a big problem.
I’m just disagreeing with Norm, respectfully as I can. If that’s pot addressing kettle, considering
how I started this report, my apologies.